36 Comments
User's avatar
Becca Parsons's avatar

I really enjoyed this piece, so much wisdom here. I was chatting with my mum a few days ago about this idea of “mom guilt” and how actually often when we feel guilt as mothers (or indeed in general) it’s because our actions in some way are not aligned with our values or desires. And so mom guilt can actually serve as an invitation to get curious about things we might want to change. I love how you’ve expanded this idea and so wisely linked it to the grief that often lies behind guilt and defensiveness. So often that grief is what we need to explore, painful though it might feel.

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Yes! I actually have another essay I'm working on about mom guilt! There's a bit more to explore there, I think, but yes, so related to this! Thanks for reading and for your kind words

Expand full comment
Annelise Roberts's avatar

This is so insightful, Amber!

I’ve seen this line a few places - “I sat with my anger long enough, and she told me she was grief” and this has been so true for me.

Anger is easier than grief because it makes us feel like we’re doing something. It also makes us cynical, judgmental and shuts relationships and understanding down. And I have to think you’re right — that so much of our anger hs actually about not having a place to put our grief.

You should look up Dan Allender’s essay, “The Hidden Hope in Lament”. I think it may be one of the most impactful things I’ve ever read about learning to grieve — to lament — well.

https://theallendercenter.org/2016/06/hidden-hope-lament/

Expand full comment
Haley Baumeister's avatar

YES. Wow.

Amber, this was so good and I appreciate this, too, Annelise. I’ve dealt with a ton of anger in the past couple years but finally realizing it’s both a symptom of some mental stuff mixed with just pure sadness over objectively disappointing or hard things (especially in motherhood). Still learning how to navigate it, but my husband is also noticing how that anger is often just a cover for being deeply sad about some things.

Amber, your explanation of thinking about schooling basically mirrors my own thoughts at the moment. (Down to having been a teacher… which honestly scarred me for life for public school on multiple levels.) But how to navigate the ideal vs. reality? It gets so tricky.

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you, Haley for sharing your reactions and experiences. It really is so tricky. And I by no means think everyone needs to homeschool or we're all doomed. I just personally feel a call to it, at least in these early years.

Expand full comment
Haley Baumeister's avatar

Yes. Absolutely get this. And footnote 2. I'm right there with you and its something that has come up with my husband and I about what is realistic given the state of things with... me already not doing great for periods of time. :)

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you, Annelise! Yeees, I've heard that line before, too! Beautiful. I will absolutely look up that essay! I'm vaguely familiar with his work from the (amazing) podcast "The Place We Find Ourselves"

Expand full comment
St. Kassia's Scribe's avatar

One area I have suppressed grief is the fact that I had to have a (potentially doubly life-saving!) c-section, when my heart had been set on a “natural” birth. I really resonate with Annelise’s comment about unrecognized grief manifesting as anger. About as soon as the c-section happened, I switched from the Natural Bandwagon to the C-Section Bandwagon. (Grief is sooo uncomfortable.) And I honestly thought I was done processing this and had fully come to terms with it, until a conversation with an acquaintance a few months ago, where she tried to inform me of all the ways you can turn a breech baby, which I had tried (investing lots of money) to no avail. (I must have just not tried hard enough or known enough!) I got super cynical and annoyed, to my own complete surprise!

Then recently, a friend posted about her amazing home birth and while I was definitely happy for her, I was definitely more than a bit envious as well.

There have definitely been Christian women voices belittling the idea of grieving, especially around the area of birth. “Who are we to be entitled to the birth of our dreams? We should be grateful to give birth to a healthy baby!” 🙄 But it’s a false dilemma. I can be grieving something, without necessarily having felt entitled to it. Feelings are almost physical, they don’t respond to moral imperatives. But that sounds like a whole ‘nother conversation!

So I’m really glad you wrote about this. Glad to know I am not alone in the endeavor of reprocessing moments that I haven’t grieved yet.

Expand full comment
NotaBot's avatar

Even though you may have come to terms with it, the issue and associated anger/grief may still rear its ugly head and need to be further processed. We are learning, growing creatures and this process is not unlike forgiveness —it’s usually not just one and done but a ‘journey’ (sorry, hackneyed) and a process.

God bless you and other commenters for your honesty and humility.

Expand full comment
Bethany Welborn's avatar

Oh, this is so helpful, as someone who can be easily offended and find myself defensive over the smallest things (I don’t want to be this way!) This is a great tool, to press in where I’m feeling defensive, and get curious about what grief I haven’t allowed myself to name or process yet. 💜

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you for your vulnerability in sharing this! We all are like this sometimes; it's very human! So you're not alone. But yes, I think it's a good general idea to be curious about our defensiveness. Thanks for reading.

Expand full comment
trisha's avatar

You can have grief and anger sharing space. A woman in our church recently said publicly “ Gods greatest honor for women is life-bearing”. I was so angry (I am an infertility-adoptive mom). while looking as childless women from 20-80 in the pews. Guess we are only worthy of second best honor!

But i still have moments of private grief and deep sadness over not able to get pregnant, which is mixed with guilt as later in life learned pregnancy would have killed me due to an aorta defect.

And all of that is the human heart

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Don’t disagree with a thing you’ve said here, sister. Thank you for sharing your experiences

Expand full comment
Amy (White) Mithelman's avatar

Wiping tears as I write this comment. Thank you for writing this! I feel extremely connected to this piece. I’m so grateful for the gift of honest self reflection and validation. You are so brave to share your insights and journey with others.

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Aw thank you friend for reading and for sharing your reaction. My writing is fun and cathartic for me, and when it feels supportive for others it makes me so happy!

Expand full comment
Jessamyn Rains's avatar

Love this, Amber.

I'm homeschooling my kids but often feel guilt/ shame over things that they're not getting because they're not going to school. The real so often doesn't live up to the ideal thing we envision. That said...I wish you all the best and all the joy!

Expand full comment
Jessamyn Rains's avatar

I left this comment...then I walked away and thought...my comment is potentially one of the triggering, insensitive comments you were talking about (although I get you're not condemning those, and that's part of the point of your essay). I should have said "the real so often doesn't live up to the ideal thing I envision, and so I sometimes doubt whether I've made the best choice, or whether I am adequate." I didn't mean to throw cold water on your joy. I truly rejoiced with you when I read that you get to homeschool your kids... I LOVE homeschooling, and I think you will be amazing as a homeschool mom. I just related (in sort of an opposite way) to what you were talking about, though my issue is self-doubt, not grief. (Did I just dig myself into a deeper hole? )Anyway, I truly wish you the best!

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

You're so thoughtful; thank you. I totally know how it is to leave a quick comment and then be like, I feel like that may be read wrong! It's ok - your experience is yours and however you relate is okay!

I read your latest by the way and I wish you the best as well with what's to come! I do hope you write more in the future!

Expand full comment
Emily Hess's avatar

Late to the party here...

We sent our oldest to public school for three years. I originally couldn't see myself as a public school mom, but it actually worked out really well. I figured we'd stick with school, and I was relieved in some ways (I was homeschooled, and my mom always seemed really miserable). I was all set to stick it out.

Then circumstances changed. We needed to homeschool; school wasn't going to work anymore. And I had to re-adjust my picture of myself all over again. We've homeschooled for a year, and I'm enjoying it more than I thought I would, thankfully.

We're asked to do and be something other than what we planned and think is ideal so very often.

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Yes yes yes. We sure are. Thank you for sharing💞

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

Wow, this resonated through and through. I had the exact same reaction that you had to Julie's post when I saw it some months ago. At that point in time, I was just starting a one year adventure in homeschooling my oldest for kindergarten, after a long wrestle with the decision. (Further processing of my own educational experience, which was being homeschooled in the ATI/fundy generation of the the 1990s/early 00s, aka a very different time; touring a ton of local schools to whittle down our options; evaluation both my child's readiness for kindergarten--verdict, not ready--and my own capacity to take it on without losing my mind). It wasn't the education part that was nerve wracking, but my own capacity to continue to be with my kids nearly 24/7, though adding in the education responsibilities on top of my own freelance work was an additional consideration. We/I decided I would homeschool him, but just for kindergarten, to give him another year of play. So when I saw her post, I was angry and super defensive. It highlighted the guilt that I already felt--that the homeschool mom of my ideals does not exist in my own person and that I wanted to, but did not, align with the viewpoint she described. You've named what I'm now seeing what I was experiencing, grief. I did not see it that way at the time, but I guess I could have maybe guessed it by the amount of times I burst into unwelcome tears when talking about this decision.

(Side note: here we are, several months later, coming to the end of the school year. He is going to 1st grade next year and I feel both relief and chagrin about that decision. And yet, I saw that as the year went on and he got older and matured before my very eyes, being home with both of my kids felt easier and less overwhelming every day. So, depending on whether or not he thrives in school (I worry about the same things you described, ie the institutional squashing of originality and creativity and even joy) I am open to doing it again.)

Expand full comment
Christina Waters's avatar

My daughter used to go to a private classical school where she surpassed every academic challenge. Now we homeschool and I’m very judgmental of myself that I am unable to challenge her at the same level as her old school. Thank you for sharing! I’ve been stuck on ruminations of my problem. It’s giving me a new perspective to ponder.

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you for reading and sharing your situation. Sending love as you navigate that!

Expand full comment
caroline benzel's avatar

I think you’re on to something here!! The sad face on the breastfeeding comment…I feel like I’ve been in some variation of that convo so many times. Would like to sit down and think about all of the times. I am a homeschooling mom who sent her kids to school and it’s a lot of feelings. Mostly relief, but also some what ifs and regrets. Beautiful essay

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you and thanks for reading Caroline

Expand full comment
Katie Raak's avatar

I am excited for your family's new homeschool adventures!

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you Katie. I'm exciting to join the ranks. Adventures seems like a good word ;)

Expand full comment
Kate D.'s avatar

Thank you for writing about grief and the defensiveness we can all react with when we haven't processed our grief.

I absolutely grew up and lived most of my life with no place for being sad. If you were just strong enough and smart enough and grateful enough, you never needed to be sad, right? Well, it turns out that unfelt-sadness comes out in other (often dysfunctional or unhealthy) ways.

I needed to let go of control, which felt impossible. It was a very difficult journey, the best bad thing that's ever happened to me. Now I can feel sad and express my sadness and I'm much healthier. It helps my parenting too, now that I really believe emotions are not right or wrong, they just are.

https://faithandwitness.org/2022/01/11/rejoice-always-toxic-positivity-depression-and-freedom-in-christ/

Expand full comment
Sadia Kalam's avatar

So glad I found this. I liked the line where your partner said, you won’t be happy. I homeschooled for 3 years and the kids are in school for 2 years, and the differences are stark. I might write about it but they made me promise never to write about them on the internet. 😅I don’t use IG or any social media platforms so I’m saved from mom shaming etc I find those spaces a little toxic for my taste and choices. But I’ve been wondering if there are other creatives who struggle with child rearing and their art. Nice to meet you Amber!

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Oh my goodness - there are so many of us! Nice to meet you, too!

Regarding homeschooling... thanks for sharing. I'm sure it's a whole thing. I'm leaving it open, for sure! It would surprise me zero percent if we sent the kids back to school at some point. Year by year, based on how we're all doing!

And yes, it's a tricky thing regarding writing about motherhood/parenting and respecting your kids as human beings. I like that Substack allows for some posts to go to only paid subscribers, which is more private.

Expand full comment
Leslie A. Mills's avatar

My husband and I were both public school kids, and, for the most part I feel like we both got a good education. By the time our kids were in school though, it was a mess. Even in what was known as the best school in the county, the teachers were the highlight; the curriculum and underlying agenda were atrocious.

I wish homeschooling were as simple as just wanting to be with my kids 24/7 - trust me, most days I didn’t / don’t (my daughter is now a sophomore in college, my son a sophomore in HS). I spent A LOT of years crying over the experiences they were having and the opportunity they were missing as public school squashed the talents and individualism right out of them. In fact, I think it’s the reason (or a big part of the reason) we’ve had so many struggles with our son who’s now declared himself an atheist.

All that to say, homeschooling is hard, but putting pressure on yourself to be “solely responsible for your child’s education,” as I’ve heard so often, isn’t accurate or necessary. Homeschooling offers a wealth of options, many of which come with pre-planned curriculum/ guidelines/ syllabi. You have options, and, in general, the homeschool community is quite supportive. Don’t give up on finding your people: those moms who will tell you the ugly truth about being with your kids 24/7 but then turn around in the next sentence and tell you how beautiful it is. You will not regret the extra time you spend with them because you can’t get the years back (and trust me, they FLY by)!

Thoroughly enjoyed this piece, by the way! (The part about grief and anger?!) So well written!

Expand full comment
Cori Meadows's avatar

Very beautifully written, Amber ♥️

Expand full comment
Amber Adrian's avatar

Thank you Cori! Thanks for reading

Expand full comment